Sunday, March 2, 2014

Graham on Confucius II: De

Scott Bradley


The little word de (te), best known as part of the title of the Daodejing (Tao Te Ching), has presented translators with many a headache. The main problem is not so much with finding the right equivalent word, though that poses one, but with understanding what it means in the first place. Graham offers a definition for its use by Confucius which might profitably be taken as the foundation for every other subsequent usage: "the power . . . to move others without exerting physical force." Here is a concept, an orientation, through which the entirety of the classical Chinese philosophic enterprise can be brought into focus.

A curious thing about classical Chinese philosophy is that it is always political. Yes, even philosophical Daoism, the supposedly "quietist" philosophy of hermits and drop-outs, is profoundly political. The most celebrated 'Daoist' work, the Daodejing, is a manual for rulers on how best to rule. And even Zhuangzi, who is said to have refused political office so he could, like a free turtle, drag his tail in the mud, does so, in part, that he might more effectively "move others without exerting physical force."

On the face of it, it seems so obvious that philosophy would always be a political enterprise. That it has often attempted to be otherwise in the West (though, in the end, nothing is not political) is in itself telling. We are, after all, communal beings. Confucius understood everything in this context. Personal ethics could not be abstracted from the network of human relationships. The point was to be a better human being so as to make for a better society. Were he to run for office today, it would be under the banner of "family values".

Zhuangzi is noteworthy for his individualism; he introduced the value of one's own self-realization outside the context of societal conventions, a personal freedom from dependence upon esteem and merit. But never is this forgetful (even when forgotten) of the benefits that accrue to society generally. The freak of "discombobulated de" is identified as praiseworthy precisely because that de extends to the material benefit of many others.

A species of fish spit on each other when the pond goes dry, Zhuangzi tells us, but how much better when there is enough water for them to forget each other in the rivers and the lakes. The best thing one person can do for another, except in situations of distress, is to leave them to find their own unique expression. De tells us, however, that this apparent gap of disinterest and forgetting is in fact spanned by what Graham calls a "charisma" that assists without assisting. It is, in part, respect for personal context, the affirming gift of allowing others to be themselves.

For Zhuangzi, as for Laozi, it is the empty space that gives value to the whole, as a window makes for the usefulness of a room, or as the realization of inner emptiness (qi) allows for light to enter the heart-mind. De is a quality that, like emptiness, gives things space to be and grow.

You can check out Scott's other miscellaneous writings here.

8 comments:

  1. I am new here but they are offering exactly what I am looking for. I want an Economics assignment help. I am in the United States, and therefore, I don’t know whether they offer the service here. If you do, let me know how much it will cost me for Economics homework help. I am waiting for their response.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My schedule is so tight and therefore I want someone to be a Matlab homework help solver who can help me complete my control systems assignment from time to time. I will be ready to give this Matlab assignment help
    expert the login details to my class so that I don’t have to check whether there are pending assignments. If there is an assignment you will just be emailing me the quotation of having the work done and then you complete it and submit it in the class portal.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm very grateful for the free corrections that you did on my Excel assignment. The corrections we're demanding, so I thought that the company was going to ask for some amount to get them done. Luckily, I learned that they do corrections without charging clients, which is very generous of you. I've worked with several Statistics Assignment Help providers, and none of them ever offered to do me corrections without a tip. I highly recommend the Statistics Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  4. The Programming Homework Help expert that they gave me was honest and free. He went on and asked if I could extend the deadline for the best grades, which I did. Food for me, he delivered what he promised; the best grade. It was a straight "A!" What was good about this was the prices. I didn't have to break the bank for the "A" like any other assignment helper would want. This time around, I'll come back to try their tutoring services, too. For now, much thanks for the C++ Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  5. Do yourself a favor and order this company's Programming Homework Help services so that they smile all the way to success. That's what happened to me a few months ago when a friend recommended it to me. I'm honestly not very good at C despite attending its classes every week. When I resorted to the company'sC Homework Helpservices, I experienced immediate changes in my academic account.

    ReplyDelete

  6. Their services seem perfect. The Statistics Assignment Help expert who completed my assignment was fast and ardent. He was also very communicative throughout the period he was undertaking the order. Moreover, he followed all my instructions to the letter. I used the Statistics Homework Help after a friend told me about it. He had used it before and was very successful. Thanks for the unmatched services and marks.

    ReplyDelete

  7. I have sent them an email to the Matlab assignment help team. It just details my assignment requirements. I need a very good Matlab homework help tutor to be handling my numerical methods assignments. This is just the start because I just enrolled in a Matlab class. I, therefore, want someone who will be available and ready to deliver my work on time. If they have one very good Matlab expert then link me with them so that we can start the work immediately.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have tried hiring them on their website and the process of hiring is indeed quite simple. What has surprised me is that they have many Economics assignment help
    professors, so I was even confused about which one to choose. I have submitted all the requirements and made the payment. I hope that I will get good Economics homework help

    ReplyDelete

Comments are unmoderated, so you can write whatever you want.