Sunday, March 1, 2009

Believing in Believing

In the last post, I shared a brief snippet from God's Debris. I purposely didn't add very much in the way of my personal analysis because I simply wanted to provide you with the opportunity to read it without taking any other opinion except your own into account. Now that several hours have passed and many of you have indeed read it, this entry is my analysis.

Before I get started, I do wish to point out why I focus on Christianity in my many critiques as opposed to other religious traditions. The reason is quite simple; I grew up in the Presbyterian Church and so Christianity is the religion I know the most about. That said, the points I will make below most assuredly apply across the board to include adherents of the other monotheistic religions and, possibly, non-monotheistic religions as well.

When the character Avatar states, “Four billion people say they believe in God, but few genuinely believe. If people believed in God, they would live every minute of their lives in support of that belief", my reaction every time is Right On!

The Christian Church is founded upon the rock of this being called Jesus Christ, yet I've never met one adherent who even minimally tries to pattern their life after the supposed master! One would think if people truly believed this human was the son of the almighty God, they would lead lives that followed his path.

Take some of the following widely held beliefs of Jesus to heart. We know he was a carpenter by trade, yet I know of no mention in the new testament of Jesus ever building or repairing anything. Evidently, he had no actual occupation other than trying to save the world.

Because he had no occupation and didn't appear to accept any form of monetary honorarium, he had no money. He also seemed to have few belongings except for the clothes on his back, his purse or satchel and, maybe, a good walking staff. He had no residence of his own either.

He never married and, by most indications, never had an intimate sexual relationship with anyone. Not surprisingly then, he had no offspring.

When he set off to go preaching -- since he had no money of his own -- he relied on the kindness and hospitality of strangers. In many respects, he was a true vagabond. He also wasn't very particular about whom he kept company with as there are several reports of his hanging out with tax collectors, prostitutes and lepers -- the outcasts of his society.

Many of his chosen disciples followed these same patterns. They walked away from their jobs and families to follow him and he sent them out to preach under the same terms as himself.

There is one other aspect of the man called Jesus I want to draw your attention to. He was apolitical. He has been quoted as stating something like render unto Caesar what is Caesar's and render unto God what is God's. When people of his day beseeched him to lead an armed revolution against the Roman occupiers, he didn't bite. His purpose wasn't to change government, but to change hearts.

Now, compare your everyday Christian to the man each says they idolize.

Most of them have jobs that occupy a great deal of their time and energy, many to the point that they neglect their families and themselves. Most of them accept money for their work and many hoard it to a vulgar extreme. They own possessions out the wazoo and they're always looking to buy more and more of them.

The vast majority are married or in a serious relationship or have engaged in sexual relationships. Christians tend to have children; some Christians have A LOT of children.

Most Christians don't tend to set off on a trip without making prior arrangement for lodging and food. The ones who hoard money stay in opulent surroundings that cater to their every whim and they have some eye-popping whims!

A great many Christians live in segregated communities -- some in gated communities -- away from whatever portion of the community they deem undesirable. Many of them will cross to the other side of the street if they even think they might come into contact with a vagabond!

And, in recent years, many sectors of Christendom have become obsessed with politics. They rail for and against political candidates from the pulpit. They pour millions of dollars into political campaigns and think tanks. A great number of them seem more concerned with changing government than changing hearts.

In essence, the lives of so-called believers and the life of their savior are as different as night and day. There is almost no semblance whatsoever of symmetry between them.

This leads me to surmise that most Christians merely believe in the act of believing without believing in the actual substance of their so-called belief. If it is otherwise, then why do they lead lives so in opposition to their hallowed role model?

13 comments:

  1. One thing Christians could do, that Jesus did, is go out into the wilderness and spend 40 days and 40 nights. The wilderness is where God lives, if you didn't know.
    But it's no wonder they don't...
    I have done it:
    I started out as a Christian, and by the time I came back, I was a Taoist.
    I have a strong suspicion that Jesus was too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jesus was not a Taoist. The historical Jesus was probably nothing more than an itinerant Jewish rabbi with some crazy ideas for his day. Very little of what one reads in the Canonical gospels (Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John) is trustworthy, having been mostly fabricated and embellished long after the fact by followers seeking to justify their made up religion.

    But people consistently read these stories and conveniently see in them just the kind of Jesus they would like him to be, be it Taoist or whatever. What's the point of that? Why do we seem to have a need to say something more than that Jesus as we know him is mostly legend, a fictional character...?

    I'm in the wilderness a lot. Funny that God must be on vacation or not at home so often.... I wonder what's up with that.... ;)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Christians are not generally a great source of information or truth:
    One told me, once, that God is a Christian.
    I had trouble with that.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Crow,
    Maybe you could offer a service to Christians to provide 40/40 guided wilderness sojourns. :)

    Forest,
    You know, you've already convinced me that no one really knows much about this Jesus fellow. That said, my post was directed at the beliefs (however misguided) of Christian adherents juxtaposed to their actual behavior. Had I questioned their most basic beliefs about JC, then the focus of debate -- if they care to weigh in -- would be centered on who JC was or wasn't, not the topic at hand.

    You see, there was a method to my madness, I think. :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. RT, my comment was actually directed at Crow's first comment, and not at the subject matter of your post. Sorry.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Never take a crow too seriously.
    A crow is is - after all - only a crow.

    ReplyDelete
  7. That's good to know, Crow. :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I was going to weigh in on this, but the comment dialogue already in place made me lose my train of thought...

    : )

    hmmm... I guess I'll just say one thing. As soon as someone - anyone - proclaims to Know something, that's usually my clue to turn around and walk the other way.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I am a Christian that wants to learn about knowing (or not knowing) Taoism.

    The observations that most Christians are greedy, self-segregating and political are what I see reported in the U.S. press. My perceptions are that most Christians in the world are needy; many, poor and rich alike, do works to help others. We mostly only hear about the few making the most waves.

    The Gospels are very allegorical and written in a culture far removed from our own; so, to assume anything factual in them can be very misleading. They provide food for reflection that can be a guide to be more loving to foster peace among us.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The historical Jesus was probably nothing more than an itinerant Jewish rabbi with some crazy ideas for his day.

    Wow um have you ever heard of the Bible? Jesus claims to be God. so either he was, he was crazy, or he was like a demon or evil spirit. "Good teacher" was not left open to us.

    In essence, the lives of so-called believers and the life of their savior are as different as night and day. There is almost no semblance whatsoever of symmetry between them.


    Wow... this post is unbelievably flawed. Are you sure you went to a Christian church? By your logic, since Christ lived in the middle east then all Christians not living there are wrong. We are not called to be carpenters, or called to never have money. We are called to be like Christ in that we must strive to be sinless and to be humble and to try to reach others for Christ. And sexual relationships really? Have you read the Bible? I guess not considering the numerous verses such as Genesis 2:24 that state- For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and they will become one flesh.

    And second of all, what does it matter? truth is truth. Just because there are some Christians who are phonies provides no evidence against Chrisitanity. zero. cero. zip. that's like saying because a million people added 2 and 2 and got 5 then clearly math is flawed.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Tye,
    I sderiously think my reply to you here will be a waste of time and will fall on deaf ears, but here goes an exaercise in futility:

    Heard of the Bible, you ask? I have a degree in it as a matter of fact, and taught it in what is probably a very similar way to the way you've been taught it from a Christian pulpit for many years. Not that that would make any difference to you, as you obviously already know and are convinced that everything you "know" and have been taught about the Bible is actually true.

    The Bible is largely a work of fiction, myth.

    The historical Jesus never claimed to be God. I'm quite sure of that. Perhaps you should read some New Testament scholars like Robert Funk or J.D. Crossan, or Marcus Borg. Not that you would or will...

    The claims of the New Testament to Jesus' divinity are yet one more fabrication on the part of followers a generation or two on(and sometimes even more, depending on the book we're talking about) to give supernatural claims and validation to their struggling and persecuted sect.

    And for centuries millions have based their lives on fictions.

    Nuff said.

    I wish you peace. Truly.

    ReplyDelete
  12. http://toughquestionsanswered.wordpress.com/

    Mr. Pratt has done an entire series on the historical accuracy of the Bible. Please read all of them and then come back and talk to me about the Bible being a work of fiction.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Argument with you is utterly pointless, and I knew it was. A waste of time and breath as is even what I am presently typing. You will choose to believe what you want to believe. Happy delusions to you.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are unmoderated, so you can write whatever you want.